Buona Sera - Red Bank, New Jersey

Analia G.

Great restaurant reviews drew us here, and it was next door to our theater venue, the Count Basie. Restaurant parking lot provided across the street, making it easy for leftovers to be dropped off as the portions are gigantic. Everything was delicious. Managers and owners came to every table. Cocktails made to the letter. Expensive and worth every dime spent. Fantastic.

Sherry J.

So let me preface this by stating I didn’t realize this was a full blown 80s club after 9pm. Went for a nice dinner after a concert. But wow 80s super loud dance floor 10 feet from my dinner table. Made it almost impossible to enjoy conversations. Waiter was not terribly attentive. Had to keep asking for basic things. Bread, then butter, then extra drinks because that was difficult to imagine bringing something other than water. Appetizers were very good. Stuffed mushrooms and fried calamari. Ordered the Pork chops and Pasta Bolognese. The pork was cooked to perfection. The bolognese was not typical. Done a little different. But still good. Dessert was good. New York cheesecake. Coffee was a challenge because he never returned with cream or sugar. Had to ask 2 waiters so by the time they brought it coffee was not hot. The waiter seemed interested in waiting on their “regulars” that this place caters to. Honestly seemed like a scene from goodfellas where only certain tables receive exclusive service. Maybe it was just that time of night or that particular waiter. Might try again

Amit B.

Updated December 2024: We revisited Buona Sera this month, and it continues to deliver the same exceptional experience we enjoyed back in 2022. The portion sizes are perfect for sharing, with generous, family-style servings that are bursting with authentic Italian flavors.

The service remains top-notch—attentive, friendly, and professional—and the ambiance is warm and inviting, ideal for both casual dinners and special occasions. Buona Sera has consistently upheld its reputation as a standout Italian restaurant in Red Bank. Highly recommended!

Mikey A.

The food here is incredible! The pizza is absolutely delicious—crispy crust, fresh toppings, and just the right amount of cheese. It’s easily one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time. They also offer amazing seafood and steaks, cooked to perfection, making it a great spot for a variety of tastes. And don’t miss out on their wonderful desserts; they are the perfect sweet ending to a fantastic meal.

The service was equally impressive. Our waiter, Julian, was superb. He came to our table promptly, took our order quickly, and made sure our food arrived in no time. Julian was very helpful throughout the meal, checking in on us to ensure everything was perfect. When it came time to leave, he packed our food quickly and efficiently, making the entire dining experience seamless.

If you’re in Neptune and craving great food with excellent service, this place is definitely worth a visit. A big thank you to Julian for making our evening so enjoyable!

Susan B.

Dinner for 4 last night at Buona Sera was super in all aspects. Our table was perfect (Upstairs), our waiter, Terry was so great, professional, yet light hearted and friendly. We appreciated his personality and helpfulness with our order, we had questions and special requests, which he offered up suggestions. The food, was wonderful! Plentiful, and so much favor. Looking forward to our next visit!

Damara D.

After moving to New Jersey from Los Angeles this is the first restaurant that has truly delivered. Beautiful atmosphere, service, and most of all the food. I made reservations for their Thanksgiving buffet, and was truly impressed. I plan to take my mom for her birthday. It’s about a half hour from home, but absolutely worth the drive.

Diana D.

This place is consistently excellent. Last night I feasted on the pork chop, French style. It was served with potatoes and your choice of sweet or hot peppers. I chose the Italian long hots. That pork chop was the best thing I have ever eaten. It was deliciously crispy on the outside and the inside melted like butter. I took half of my half portion home. My only regret was not ordering the full portion so I could have more leftover. Atmosphere is lovely, but beware you’re packed in tight and it’s loud.

Ray F.

Outstanding restaurant and food. Mr. Whelan, host was exceptional and super friendly!!! We can’t wait to come back. Large servings of food and no need to eat for two days after coming here!!!! Service was exceptional and owner visited every table, classy restaurant all around with great ambiance.